Anton Community Newspapers  •  132 East 2nd Street  •  Mineola, NY 11501  •  Phone: 516-747-8282  •  FAX: 516-742-5867
Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrintE-mail

Residents Speak Out At Redistricting Hearing

Last year’s political battle over new district lines in county still casts a shadow over current proceedings

While Nassau County Temporary Redistricting Commission Chairman Frank Moroney said at the commission’s first meeting that the controversial proposed 2011 redistricting map, drawn by the Republican-dominated county legislature, was not to be considered, residents clearly aren’t convinced the map is gone for good. At the redistricting hearing held on Monday, Oct. 22 at Plainview-Old Bethpage John F. Kennedy High School, many of the 20-plus speakers expressed concerns about the 2011 map, especially the fact that it divided Plainview into four legislative districts. In addition, even if a new map is to be drawn, many expressed skepticism that it could be done in a truly fair and bipartisan way.

Legislator David Denenberg was blunt in his assessment of the blatantly political nature of the Republican-drawn map. “Everyone knows that when it comes to redistricting, the map that was presented last year had one thing in mind, and that was that the Republicans could have a supermajority in the legislature,” Denenberg said. “There’s no way you can tell me that half a million people moving into new districts was about the people and not about the parties.”

Many agreed with Denenberg and demanded answers of the commission: Why did the proposed plan divide Plainview into so many pieces? Why did it divide communities along local streets? Why did it move Democratic legislators like Judy Jacobs and Denenberg himself out of their communities? However, the commissioners were clear that they were there to focus on new maps; they were not responsible for drawing the old ones, thus could not answer these questions.

“We don’t have a preconceived idea about what the new map should look like, so we want to get input from every community and see what you have to say,” said Democratic Commissioner Bonnie Garone.

However, at this time the 2011 map could still be implemented by the legislature; while the process the Republican majority used to try to institute the map in 2011 was deemed in violation of the county charter by the NYS court of appeals last year, the map itself has not been invalidated. None of the commissioners made any statements on the topic of whether or not the 2011 map would be put back on the table at some point, although many speakers alluded to that possibility.

In the interests of going forward, Legislator Jacobs stated that there was a window of opportunity present for Democrats and Republicans to work together, and that doing so would be the best way to honor the memory of friend and colleague Peter Schmitt, the former presiding officer of the legislature who died suddenly on Oct. 3. Jacobs also pointed out some interesting facts: while the lines that were drawn at the time of the legislature’s formation were said to heavily favor Republicans, a Democratic majority eventually took over in the late ’90s. Similarly, while the 2003 lines were said to favor Democrats, under those same lines the Republicans were able to win back control of the Legislature just a few years ago.

“This just goes to show, the people of Nassau County are very smart; the people of Nassau County cannot necessarily be dictated to,” said Jacobs.

In general, speakers asked the commissioners to keep communities that were united by a single school district, such as Plainview-Old Bethpage and Syosset-Woodbury, within the same district. Speakers also asked that the commissioners consider communities, rather than geographic features, when creating new districts.

“It’s the people who live and pay taxes and raise their families in the communities that ought to be your sole consideration, once we get past one person, one vote. Not separating communities of interest is extremely important,” said Barbara Sullivan-Parry of Oyster Bay.

On the subject of Plainview in particular, Larry Weiss pointed out that being politically divided already hurts Plainview: the area is separated into two congressional districts, two state senate districts, and two assembly districts. Weiss, who organized the recent Plainview Chamber of Commerce Meet the Candidates Breakfast, said that because the area made up such a small part of so many elected officials’ territories, many of those invited didn’t bother to show up. Assemblyman Charles Lavine agreed.

“Any plan that is going to bisect, trisect or eviscerate Plainview is going to simply serve to lessen whatever political clout, whatever social clout this community has,” Lavine stated.

The most outspoken in his skepticism was Henry Boitel of Rockville Centre, who said he started out optimistic that the commission would bring a citizen’s perspective to redistricting, but no longer believes that to be the case. Boitel stated that while the commission keeps holding hearings asking for feedback, the only meeting of substance where the commissioners tried to determine the ground rules for their procedure ended with the parties being unable to agree.

“You’ve got five Democrats and five Republicans who will probably be acting as though they are Democrats and Republicans and as an extension of the legislators that appointed them, rather than an independent, citizen’s commission looking out for the welfare of the county,” said Boitel.

Boitel went on to state that the commission’s website lacks information about the population imbalance that the redistricting is ostensibly being done to correct. Francesca Carlow also mentioned the website, asking for greater legibility for the new map or maps when they are uploaded; the commissioners seemed to agree with Carlow’s assessment that the 2011 map was not easily readable.

Still, whether they expressed skepticism about the process or were coming from a more positive angle, just about everyone who spoke urged the commissioners to do their very best to be fair and serve the people of Nassau County, not the parties. “Use your very best efforts to make sure that whatever product is the end result is not going to be viewed as a product of partisan cynicism,” said Lavine.

Legislator Delia DeRiggi-Whitton also crystallized the concerns of many when she spoke about the possibilities of a Republican supermajority in the legislature, which would allow the County Executive to move forward with his bonding plans.

“Don’t trust government; it’s always good to have two sides looking at whatever it is, especially when it comes to borrowing our children’s money,” said the legislator.

A revised district map must be submitted to the legislature by Jan. 5, 2013, and the legislature has until Mar. 5 to revise, adopt, or reject the map.


One local playwright and his company — The Plainview Project — seem to be headed to the big leagues.

Claude Solnik of Plainview, the Plainview Project’s writer, is married with two children. While he has a master’s degree in dramatic writing from New York University, after graduating he ended up going into journalism, which currently remains his day job. But in his free time he indulged in his true passion, hammering out numerous play scripts until the day they he realized that he needed to stop sitting on these works he was creating and put them in the hands of actors that could give them life.

Even as they hoped the parties would reach a last-minute settlement, commuters across Long Island were scrambling last week to devise alternate plans for getting to work if Long Island Rail Road’s 5,400 workers go on strike July 20. And they were vocal in their anger with the Metropolitan Transit Authority. The strike, it seems, has roused commuter ire over a wide range of LIRR issues, from timeliness to cleanliness to costs.

“I’ll have to figure out a new way home from work,” said Marco Allicastro, a 20-year-old Queens resident waiting for a train home at the Bethpage station after a day’s work at the local King Kullen. “Long Island doesn’t really have a lot of options in terms of transportation. Maybe I should get a new job.”


Sonny And Perley

Saturday, July 26

Women Artists You Should Know

Thursday, July 31

Adult Summer Reading Club

Through Aug. 7


1959: The Year The Music Stopped Playing
Written by Michael A. Miller,

The Eccentric Heiress Of ‘Empty Mansions’
Written by Mike Barry,

Yellow Margarine And A Pitch For The Ages
Written by Michael A. Miller,