Anton Community Newspapers  •  132 East 2nd Street  •  Mineola, NY 11501  •  Phone: 516-747-8282  •  FAX: 516-742-5867
Attention: open in a new window. PDFPrintE-mail

Remediation Of Marina

The Department of Environmental Conservation (DEC) held a public meeting at the Locust Valley Library to discuss the possible remediation plans for the former Mill Neck Bay Marina property. The meeting was well attended by local residents, as well as Tara Butler Sahai of Assemblyman Chuck Lavine’s office, Mayor Doug Watson of the Village of Bayville, Nassau County Legislator Don McKenzie, representatives from the Town of Oyster Bay and local civic organizations, as well as Harvey Weisman, one of the owners of the property. Friends of the Bay was represented by Executive Director Paul D’Orsay, Board President Barry Lamb, and board member Matt Meng.

Bob Corcoran, of the Division of Environmental Remediation of the DEC, explained the Proposed Remedial Action Plan (PRAP) for the property, which includes results of soil and sediment testing and provides a characterization of the site and an assessment of current conditions.

The site is 1.9 acres, and is currently divided into nine tax parcels, with space set aside for an extension of Meadow Lane through the middle of the property, which would provide access to all the parcels. At this point in time, the site is zoned for single family residential use. The marina, which operated until 2001, was given a special use variance to operate there. The marina pre-dated the current Town of Oyster Bay zoning.

The DEC found 21 metals at the site. Most of these metals are naturally occurring; however, five metals, including arsenic, mercury, lead, copper and cadmium, are present at higher levels than would be allowed if the site were to be restored for single family residential use. They would be acceptable for commercial use. Corcoran explained this by giving the example that if used for homes, homeowners would be digging into the ground to plant trees, or other kinds of activities that would disturb the soil, whereas commercial uses would not. He went on to say that the groundwater at the site has not been contaminated.

The zoning is an important consideration, as the DEC is required to see that the property is rezoned to the current land use conditions. According to a DEC factsheet distributed at the meeting, “The remedial objective for this site is to achieve residential use soil cleanup standards. This can be accomplished with the removal of all surface and subsurface soil which exceeds the residential use soil cleanup objectives.”

Estimated costs for this cleanup range from a high of $2,100,000 to achieve pre-disposal conditions, $1,600,000 for residential use, $353,000 for restricted residential use or $60,000 if the site was rezoned to commercial use. There were many questions from audience members as to who would pay for this cleanup, and what are the alternatives.

Once a remedial action plan is chosen, the state will proceed with the cleanup, regardless. If the owner is not willing to pay, the state will try to recover the costs from the owners. At this point, Weisman spoke up to say that of the four original owners, two are deceased, another has terminal cancer, and he is not well himself. He said he is willing to pay a reasonable cost for the cleanup, if the town is willing to purchase it.

Residents in the area expressed that they would like to see the area kept as open space, to be used as a passive park, for bird watching, possibly as a kayak launch. This would require a change of zoning from the Town of Oyster Bay, since the DEC is obligated by law to restore the site to what it is currently zoned for. This point was reiterated several times during the evening by DEC representatives.

Other concerns expressed by the local residents included what changes may happen to the flow of the groundwater during the cleanup, if homes are constructed there would that cause a backup of water into their homes, and how the soil would be contained on the property during the remediation process.

In response to questioning from residents, the DEC said that if the town gave a commitment to the DEC that the property would be rezoned to allow its use as a park, then they could recommend a remediation plan which would allow that use. Without a commitment to rezone the property, they are obligated by state law to restore the property to single family residential use.

It will be at least a year before any work is done. The DEC wants to choose a plan by March 31; however, if they receive many comments on the proposed plan, or depending on what course the Town of Oyster Bay may wish to pursue with regard to zoning, that may change.

The proposal is available for review at the Oyster Bay and Locust Valley libraries, or can be accessed through the DEC website at www.dec.ny.gov/docs/remediation_hudson_pdf/130166rod.pdf. Comments can be made directly to Bob Corcoran, the project engineer, at This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it or to This e-mail address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it .

News

On Saturday, July 5, Building J on the Western Waterfront was opened to the public for a free concert of classical music played by talented youth in the Oyster Bay Music Festival. The acoustics in the large metal shed were lively as the backdrop of the Ida May, a wooden oyster dredge under construction, lent artisanal flavor to the rich stew of mostly sea-related musical selections. People sat on stacks and benches of freshly milled wood or stood in the cavernous space. They soaked in beautiful solos, duets and trios that combined voice, piano, flute, cello and violin. Frank M Flower & Sons provided fresh oysters that engaged the palate, and representatives from Steinway & Sons gave a quick overview of how their pianos are made, relating several aspects of their meticulous process to the construction of the Ida May.

Last week was one of Oyster Bay’s biggest, most anticipated summer events, the Italian American Society’s St. Rocco’s Festival. Returning to its usually spot in Fireman’s Field on Shore Avenue, the festival was filled with amusement rides, live music, and great food and company.

“We come every year to St. Rocco’s with friends,” said Laura Regan of East Norwich. “The rides and awesome food make it a lot of fun.”


Sports

Oakcliff’s intensive training program provided a high level of competition last weekend at the U.S. Women’s Match Racing Championship in Oyster Bay.

This year, the teams selected for the event were highly ranked through the United States, and several of the competitors are past and current Oakcliff trainees, including Elizabeth Shaw, Kathryn Shiber, Madeline Gill, and Danielle Gallo.

A total of 11 members of St. Dominic Track Team (grades 1-8) recently medaled at the Nassau-Suffolk CYO Championship Finals at Mitchel Field. In the finals, the athletes competed against the finalists from all three regions, representing more than 2,500 athletes from 23 other parishes.

In addition to the student athletes’ success, the track coaches were honored as well. St. Dominic CYO Track coaches Phil Schade (grades 1-3), Julie and Mike Keffer (grades 4-6) and Rich Cameron (grades 7-8) were selected by peer coaches in their region for the NSCYO Team Sportsmanship Award. The Saint Dominic CYO track program, in its second year, has already proven to be a force to be reckoned with and the young runners are among the best on Long Island.


Calendar

OB Band Concerts

Wednesday, July 23

Music Under The Stars

Friday, July 25

Annual Chicken BBQ

Saturday, July 26



Columns

1959: The Year The Music Stopped Playing
Written by Michael A. Miller, mmillercolumn@gmail.com

The Eccentric Heiress Of ‘Empty Mansions’
Written by Mike Barry, MFBarry@optonline.net

Yellow Margarine And A Pitch For The Ages
Written by Michael A. Miller, mmillercolumn@gmail.com